CANTON Dismissal of a rape case last month in St. Lawrence County Court is turning political.
At Mondays St. Lawrence County Board of Legislators meeting, Legislator Kevin D. Acres, R-Madrid, asked County Administrator Karen M. St. Hilaire about the countys oversight of the office of District Attorney Nicole M. Duvé, based on the Nov. 26 dismissal of four counts of second-degree rape and four counts of endangering the welfare of a child against Kurtis P. Moore, Massena.
I try not to insert myself because I dont think its appropriate, Ms. St. Hilaire said. I am aware there were some issues.
The case against Mr. Moore, 20, was dismissed in response to a request from Public Defender Stephen D. Button on the grounds that the case had not been handled in the timely fashion required under state law.
Massena police on Feb. 7, 2011, alleged that Mr. Moore, 43 Martin St., who was 18 at the time, had sexual intercourse with a 14-year-old girl on four occasions from July 1 to Christmas 2010.
In court, Assistant District Attorney Amanda N. Nissen said the DAs office had never received the case file. Judge Jerome J. Richards then granted the defense motion.
In her response to the defense motion, Ms. Duvé wrote that review of her offices databases and open files reveals the arresting agency did not forward an arrest packet and thus no file was ever opened by the District Attorneys Office.
Massena Police Chief Timmy J. Currier disagreed.
We have documentation on our end that this case was provided to their office, Chief Currier said Tuesday.
He declined to elaborate on when the case was forwarded, saying that he had not yet spoken with Ms. Duvé about how the case was handled.
But I am disappointed that this case was dropped, Chief Currier said.
Ms. Duvé said Tuesday that she is not looking to blame anyone, least of all the police.
Our office receives and opens well over 4,000 files on an annual basis, she said, calling the criminal justice system a human institution made up of imperfect human beings.
A diligent search of the records and files in our office did not reveal that we had received an arrest packet in this particular case, Ms. Duvé said. This is not a common occurrence. This is not a regular occurrence.
The district attorney said she would be happy to talk with law enforcement officials about how best to prevent similar incidents.
But I am not blaming anybody, Ms. Duvé said. I know how much hard work they do on a daily basis.
Regardless of what happened, the matter is not for lawmakers to debate, said Legislator Frederick S. Morrill, D-DeKalb Junction, who shut down discussion at the meeting by saying the board lacked jurisdiction.
Im guessing he brought it up as a political issue, Mr. Morrill said of Mr. Acres. I just thought it was an improper place. Thats a different branch of government. Our job is to provide resources. Cases, I think, are off-limits to us.
Republicans have targeted Ms. Duvé, a Democrat who is up for re-election next year, although candidates have not yet come forward.
Mr. Morrill said legislators in the past have been disgruntled by some judicial issues, such as the countys payments for the defense of Wayne T. Oxley Jr. who was found innocent at his third trial for murder but understand their role is limited.
Legislators can say only so much when the department head answers to the public, said Legislative Chairwoman Sallie A. Brothers, D-Norfolk.
Once youre an elected official, theres a limit to what we can do administratively, she said. We have the right to express disappointment, but we cant make the district attorney function differently.
Regardless of whether he should criticize, Mr. Acres said, the fact remains that a case involving a 14-year-old goes unprosecuted.
Mr. Button requested dismissal of the Moore case because the states Criminal Procedure Law permits the termination of a felony prosecution that has not been presented to a grand jury or otherwise resolved within a year of arraignment.
Mr. Moore was arraigned Feb. 7, 2011, by Massena Village Justice Eric J. Gustafson and released under the supervision of the Probation Department.
Mr. Button said his office was assigned to Mr. Moores case Feb. 22, 2011. In a March 8, 2011, local court appearance, his office waived the matter to County Court to await grand jury presentment, Mr. Button said.
Mr. Moore remains free on probation while awaiting sentencing in February in an unrelated burglary case, in which he pleaded guilty in October to breaking into the pro shop at Massena Country Club on Sept. 23, 2011.