Was Jeb Bush right to insert love into a political debate?
Such was the gist of a question I was asked on talk radio in response to the former Florida governors assertion that some immigrants come into the United States illegally as an act of love.
It would be trite to echo the Beatles a half-decade later and say, All You Need Is Love. It would also oversimplify and obscure rigorous policy differences. But it also could be a start.
It was decades ago when I first heard someone suggest higher fences — wired for electricity — as the optimum solution for any and all immigration problems. The commenter may have been half-joking, but the sentiment exists, and its distressing. To borrow a phrase from Boys Town, hes not an illegal, hes my brother.
Thats the point Cardinal Sean OMalley and others were making earlier this month when they celebrated Mass at a Mexico border crossing in Phoenix.
For two decades, OMalley, the current cardinal archbishop of Boston, worked with immigrants in Washington, D.C. At the Mass, he said: I often share the story of my first days at the Centro Catolico, when I was visited by a man from El Salvador who sat at my desk and burst into tears as he handed me a letter from his wife back in El Salvador, who remonstrated him for having abandoned her and their six children to penury and starvation.
The man in OMalleys anecdote had been putting all his earnings in an envelope, which he put in what hed been told was the mailbox on the corner. In truth, it was a fancy trash can, and his money was being stolen. When we talk politics, this is what we ought to bear in mind: people, humiliations, hopes and dreams, pain and heartache. And, yes, love.
To circle to another contentious issue, thanks to the relentless work of the Chiaroscuro Foundation, it was recently revealed that tanning salons in my homeland of New York City are more frequently visited by health inspectors than abortion clinics.
At the Mass at the border, Cardinal OMalley and other bishops of the United States were following in a model set by Pope Francis, who has implored us to stop ignoring our brothers on the side of the road, to refuse to be indifferent to the plight of our brothers and sisters in pain.
Perhaps thats what Jeb Bush had in mind. And perhaps thats why Bishop James D. Conley recently wrote about in a pastoral letter titled The Language of Love. He, too, like Pope Francis and Cardinal OMalley, is imploring people. The topic of his letter was contraception.
(Kathryn Lopez is the editor-at-large of National Review Online www.nationalreview.com. She can be contacted at firstname.lastname@example.org.)